Are non-disparagement clauses in employment NDAs enforceable against honest Glassdoor or LinkedIn reviews?
Are non-disparagement clauses enforceable against honest reviews? Generally, no. Learn how the NLRB and state laws protect your right to speak out.
Are non-disparagement clauses enforceable against honest reviews?
In most cases, non-disparagement clauses are unenforceable when applied to honest reviews about working conditions. The National Labor Relations Board (NLRB) has established that employees have a protected right to discuss their employment terms, and broad gag orders that prevent such speech violate Section 7 of the National Labor Relations Act (NLRA).
The Legal Landscape: Why Broad Clauses Fail
For decades, employers inserted "catch-all" non-disparagement clauses into separation and employment agreements. However, the 2023 NLRB decision in McLaren Macomb fundamentally shifted the power dynamic. The Board ruled that offering an agreement with overly broad non-disparagement provisions is, in itself, a violation of the NLRA because it coerces employees into waiving their statutory rights.
Protected Concerted Activity
Under the NLRA, "concerted activity" includes discussions among employees regarding their wages, hours, and working conditions. Posting a review on Glassdoor or LinkedIn regarding your experience is often viewed as an extension of this protected activity. If your review focuses on management practices, pay transparency, or workplace culture, it is likely shielded from contractual restriction.
Key takeaway: If your contract prohibits you from making any "negative statements" about the company, it is likely overbroad and legally unenforceable under current NLRB standards.
Action Item: Review your separation agreement for a "carve-out" clause. If the agreement does not explicitly state that it does not restrict your rights under the NLRA, it may be legally deficient.
Defamation vs. Disparagement: The Critical Distinction
It is vital to distinguish between "disparagement" and "defamation." Disparagement is a contractual concept; defamation is a tort. Even if a non-disparagement clause is unenforceable, you are still subject to defamation laws.
| Feature | Disparagement (Contractual) | Defamation (Tort) |
|---|---|---|
| Basis | Breach of Contract | False Statement of Fact |
| Truth Defense | Irrelevant (usually) | Absolute Defense |
| Standard | Subjective "Negative" | Objective Falsehood |
| Remedy | Damages/Injunction | Damages/Reputation Repair |
The Truth Defense
If you post a review on Glassdoor, the most effective shield is the truth. Defamation requires the plaintiff to prove that you made a false statement of fact that caused them harm. If your review is based on documented experiences, it is not defamatory, regardless of what your NDA says.
Action Item: Keep a "paper trail" of your workplace experiences. If you intend to post a review, ensure your claims are supported by emails, performance reviews, or pay stubs to establish the factual basis of your statements.
Jurisdictional Protections and Anti-SLAPP Laws
Beyond federal labor law, many states have enacted Anti-SLAPP (Strategic Lawsuits Against Public Participation) statutes. These laws are designed to prevent companies from using the legal system to bully former employees into silence.
- California: Offers robust protections against lawsuits targeting protected speech.
- New York: Recently expanded its anti-SLAPP law to cover a wider range of public interest communications.
- Texas: Provides for the immediate dismissal of lawsuits that infringe on the right to petition or free speech.
If an employer sues you for a review, an anti-SLAPP motion can force the company to pay your legal fees if they cannot prove their case has a high probability of success.
Checklist: Is Your Review Protected?
- Is the content factual? Stick to objective observations rather than hyperbolic insults.
- Does it relate to working conditions? Discussions about pay, safety, and management style are highly protected.
- Is it a matter of public interest? Reviews that warn other potential employees about systemic issues are generally viewed favorably by courts.
- Does the contract have a savings clause? Look for language that says "Nothing in this agreement shall limit the employee's rights under the NLRA."
Key takeaway: Never sign an agreement that lacks a specific carve-out for your rights to participate in government investigations or discuss working conditions.
Action Item: Before signing any severance or separation agreement, use a tool like TermScore to flag non-disparagement clauses that lack the necessary legal carve-outs required by the NLRB.
How TermScore Protects You
Navigating the fine print of employment contracts is difficult, but you don't have to do it alone. TermScore uses advanced AI to instantly analyze your contracts, identifying overbroad non-disparagement clauses and other restrictive covenants that may be unenforceable. By highlighting these "red flag" provisions, TermScore empowers you to negotiate with confidence and ensure your rights remain protected.
TermScore Research
Our legal AI analyzes thousands of contracts to surface market standards, common pitfalls, and actionable insights for anyone who signs agreements.
Get the contract red-flag checklist
Join landlords and freelancers getting clause breakdowns and benchmark data. No spam.